April 29, 2024
What has been the Government of India's response to CBAM?

The European Union's (EU) Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) has sent ripples across the globe, particularly for countries like India with significant exports to the EU. Designed to address carbon leakage and incentivize environmentally responsible production, CBAM places a carbon cost on specific imported goods entering the EU market. With Indian sectors like steel, aluminium, cement, and fertilisers falling under CBAM's initial focus, the Government of India has taken a multi-pronged approach to address the challenges and opportunities presented by this new regulation.

Understanding CBAM and its Implications for India

CBAM essentially places a carbon price on specific imported goods based on their embedded carbon emissions. This aims to level the playing field for EU producers who adhere to stricter environmental regulations and discourage companies from relocating to regions with less stringent policies (carbon leakage). Here's a breakdown of how CBAM could impact India:

  • Increased Production Costs for Exporters: Calculating and reporting carbon emissions, potentially investing in cleaner technologies, and purchasing CBAM certificates will raise production costs for Indian exporters. This could squeeze profit margins and make Indian goods less price-competitive in the EU market.
  • Shifting Market Dynamics: EU buyers could be incentivized to source from regions with stricter environmental regulations. Indian exporters might need to diversify their markets or enhance their sustainability credentials to remain attractive.
  • Potential Loss of Competitiveness: EU-produced goods with a lower carbon footprint will be relatively cheaper. Indian exporters might need to find ways to improve their carbon footprint or adjust prices to stay competitive.

The Government of India's Response: A Multi-Faceted Approach

Since the announcement of CBAM, the Indian government has taken proactive steps to address the concerns of Indian exporters and explore potential solutions. Here's a closer look at some key aspects of the government's response:

  • Engaging with the EU: The Indian government has actively engaged with the EU Commission to voice concerns about CBAM's potential impact on Indian exports. Discussions focus on ensuring a fair and transparent implementation process that considers the developmental needs of India.
  • Exploring Legal Options: The Indian government is evaluating the possibility of challenging CBAM at the World Trade Organization (WTO) if it is deemed discriminatory or protectionist. This could involve raising concerns about compatibility with WTO principles of free and fair trade.
  • Promoting Domestic Carbon Pricing Mechanisms: The government is considering the implementation of a domestic carbon tax or emissions trading scheme. This could not only incentivize cleaner production practices domestically but also potentially serve as a benchmark for calculating CBAM liability. A well-designed domestic carbon pricing mechanism could put Indian exporters on a more competitive footing.
  • Fostering Innovation and Green Technologies: The government recognizes the need for investments in clean technologies and research & development (R&D) to reduce the carbon footprint of Indian industries. Initiatives like production-linked incentives (PLIs) for green sectors and support for renewable energy adoption can play a crucial role in achieving this goal.
  • Focus on Sustainability Reporting and Transparency: The government is emphasising the importance of robust sustainability reporting by Indian companies. This could involve mandating standardised reporting frameworks and encouraging third-party verification of sustainability data. Transparent reporting practices can build trust with EU buyers and demonstrate India's commitment to environmental responsibility.

Challenges and Opportunities: The Road Ahead

The Government of India's response to CBAM reflects a careful balancing act between protecting Indian exporters and promoting sustainable practices. While there are challenges ahead, there are also opportunities:

  • Challenges: Navigating the legal complexities of CBAM implementation and WTO disputes can be time-consuming. Additionally, achieving significant reductions in the carbon footprint of key industries requires substantial investments and technological advancements.
  • Opportunities: CBAM can be a catalyst for India's transition towards a more sustainable and low-carbon economy. By embracing clean technologies and innovation, Indian industries can not only become more competitive in the global market but also contribute to a greener future. Additionally, focusing on transparency and robust sustainability reporting practices can enhance India's image as a responsible trading partner.

Ready to Supercharge Your Sustainability?

Ready to achieve BRSR excellence with comprehensive BRSR services?

Let's discuss how our BRSR services can
be the catalyst for your business growth.

Discover More